Yoo’s Supervisors Didn’t Know about the July 13, 2002 Fax
As I pointed out in my last post, when Jonathan Fredman wrote the Abu Zubaydah torture team in Thailand to tell them they had gotten the green light to torture, he cited not the Bybee One memo which had just been signed, but a July 13, 2002 Yoo fax, for his discussion of intent.
This is significant not just because the language on intent in the fax lacks some of the caveats in the Bybee One Memo. But also because it appears Yoo was freelancing when he wrote the July 13 fax.
To be sure, the evidence that Yoo was freelancing when he wrote this fax is not as clear cut as it was for the Legal Principles/Bullet Point documents. Unlike the Legal Principles documents, this fax is on OLC stationary and signed by Yoo, making it appear, at least, like a formal OLC opinion.
But Yoo’s superiors at DOJ claim to have known nothing about it.
In response to July 2008 questions from the Senate Armed Services Committee, Jay Bybee said in October 2008 that he did not recall any written guidance to CIA before the August 1 memo.
Judge Bybee said that he did not recall “any written advice provided to any governmental agency prior to August 1, 2002, on the meaning of the standards of conduct required for interrogation under the federal anti-torture statute or on specific interrogation methods,”
Similarly, when asked in July 2008 whether anyone from his department had authorized torture before August 1, 2002, John Ashcroft claimed he “didn’t know.”
Mr. NADLER. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Attorney General Ashcroft, in your testimony you mentioned Abu Zubaydah, who was captured in March 2002. The Inspector General report on the FBI’s role in interrogation makes clear that he was interrogated beginning in March of that year. The Yoo-Bybee legal memo was not issued until August 2002. So was the interrogation of Abu Zubaydah before August 2002 done without DOJ legal approval?
Mr. ASHCROFT. I don’t know.
Mr. NADLER. Well, did you offer legal approval of interrogation methods used at that time?
Mr. ASHCROFT. At what time, sir?
Mr. NADLER. Prior to August of 2002, March 2002.
Mr. ASHCROFT. I have no recollection of doing that at all.
Mr. NADLER. And you don’t know if anyone else from the Department of Justice did?
Mr. ASHCROFT. I don’t know.
[snip]
Mr. WEXLER. So from March to August, did you offer any legal approval of the interrogation methods used at that time?
Mr. ASHCROFT. I don’t have any recollection of doing so.
Mr. WEXLER. And did anyone else at the Department of Justice?
Mr. ASHCROFT. I don’t know. I don’t know.
And there is evidence that Jack Goldsmith didn’t learn about it until just before he left DOJ.