Freedom And Equality: Anderson Against Libertarianism
Libertarianism has a hole in the middle the size of the rest of society.
Notre Dame undergrad (math); JD, Indiana University at Bloomington; 1st Lieutenant, US Army.; private practice in corporate and securities law; Assistant AG in Tennessee for consumer protection and securities; Blue Sky Securities Commissioner, Tennessee; private practice, bankruptcy and corporate law.
I have had a lifelong interest in economics. For most of my career, that interest was practical, focused on the problems in front of me. Lately I have been more interested in economics as a theory, especially its impact on the lives of people like those I met in my bankruptcy practice, and on the politics of money in the US. I also enjoy reading philosophers, starting in college and steadily expanding my reading ever since. I wrote at FireDogLake for a number of years.
Generally, I think the problem facing the US is the dominance of neoliberal discourse. I think it clouds the vision, and limits the kinds of problems that can be identified and solved. For example, the existence and danger of climate change can easily be identified in a scientific discussion. However, the problem does not fit the neoliberal discourse because science insists that the pursuit of individual and corporate self-interest will lead to devastation. In neoliberal discourse, the pursuit of self-interest always leads to Eden.
The neoliberal project has two prongs. One is the police function of crushing dissent and alternative views. The police function is provided by government agencies and private and institutional actors. The counterpart is the economic system , which is operated by government and by private and institutional actors. Some of these actors operate in both spheres. I focus on the second prong.
Libertarianism has a hole in the middle the size of the rest of society.
Relational Equality is the cornerstone of democracy.
Equality is primarily about social relations, and only secondarily about the distribution of material goods.
Ahab, driven by some unknown force, chases a whale into his own watery grave, and takes the crew with him.
No one has to beg for equality in a decent society.
A decent society is based on freedom from domination.
Are freedom and inequality in conflict? How can we have a democracy if they are?
Ishmael demonstrates fundamental American values, that must be part of any social or political change.
The Democrats must act like a real political party. Activists have to try new ways to communicate. What we’re doing now isn’t working.
The conventional wisdom dug this hole. It won’t get us out.